What is the Difference between MBSE and Document-Based Systems Engineering?

There are several types of systems, two major ones being MBSE and DBSE (Model based system engineering vs Document-based systems engineering).

To be an expert in systems engineering it is important to know the difference between them. Furthermore, choosing the most suitable model for the job will be possible through this. If so, this article will discuss the differences between these two systems as well as the advantages and disadvantages of each type of system. As a result, we will be aware of the appropriate use, timing, and application.

Related: MBSE vs Traditional Systems Engineering

What is a Document-Based System?

Developing a complex plan for engineering projects is like document-based systems engineering (DBSE). DBSE is the production, administration, and planning of extensive documentation that describe every component of the system. These documents serve as the foundation for the entire system development process and serve as a database for requirements, design choices, test processes, and other information. With DBSE, knowledge is structured and transferred with clarity, consistency, and care. This is made possible by the ability engineers must navigate the complexity of a system by going back to explicitly defined specifics. For individuals who like written documentation, it gives a tried-and-true procedure that has been the foundation of engineering practices for decades. It also delivers reliability and correctness.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of the DBSE system?

One of the main advantages of document-based systems engineering is the organized and concrete approach it provides. This is one method by which engineers can provide targeted, explicit, and accurate documentation about each component of the system. These records serve as a reliable source of information, ensuring consistency throughout the project. Another advantage of DBSE is that it promotes rigor, methodical problem solving and "robotic" thinking. However, the disadvantages of this technology are many. The notable disadvantage of DBSE is that it can be time-consuming and error prone. Creating and managing multiple documents is a lot of work and keeping them up to date can be challenging and time-consuming. In addition, reliance on written documentation alone can inhibit real-time changes and collaboration. In addition, presenting complicated systems can be challenging if only textual documents are used. The sheer amount of documentation is another disadvantage as it can be overwhelming and cause knowledge overload.

MBSE system - what does it mean?

Model-based systems engineering (MBSE) is a methodology that creates complex systems using digital models. Consider developing a virtual representation of the system that can be explored in detail, like a 3D simulation or computer game. In a similar vein, these digital representations serve as a form of blueprint for the system's virtual elements, actions, and communications. Before implementing the systems in practice, models can be used to understand how the system works, test different situations and adjust and improvements. MBSE is revolutionizing the way we design and build things by using digital models, making the field more efficient and effective.

These are the advantages and disadvantages of the MBSE system:

Model-based systems engineering (MBSE) has several significant advantages, but also some challenges to consider. First, MBSE allows engineers to create digital models that act like virtual blueprints of complex systems. By doing this it is easier and more convenient to understand how things work and make improvements before building something physical. They also facilitate collaboration with other developers, as the digital model can be shared. Another advantage is that MBSE allows live updates and changes, a matter that helps in terms of time flexibility. However, there are some drawbacks. Creating digital models can be complex and time consuming and requires specific software and expertise. Thus, sometimes virtual models do not include all the details accurately, which can lead to potential problems when implementing the design in the real world. Despite these challenges, MBSE is considered a central methodology that helps to design, simulate, and optimize complex systems in a more efficient and innovative, practical, and effective way.

What is the preferred methodology?

MBSE uses digital models, while document-based systems engineering records system information on paper using traditional methods. There are 3 key distinctions: First, while DBSE focuses on written data, MBSE leverages digital models to offer dynamic and visual representations. Second, DBSE typically requires a lot of document management, but MBSE increases teamwork and collaboration through shared platforms that enable real-time changes. Third, while MBSE offers flexibility and adaptability by allowing rapid changes to digital models, DBSE may be more limited and time-consuming. This way we will know how to adapt the systems to our needs.

Do you need help developing complex systems? We invite you to read more about ptg and the services we offer to organizations here.